There’s no shortage of great Italian food in Downingtown. From meatballs to lasagna to chicken parmesan, you can enjoy the taste of fresh, delectable bites throughout the 19335 zip code. Our team has created a list of the very best Italian food restaurants across our community.
La Sponda | 20 E. Lancaster Avenue
This upscale eatery is known for their fresh seafood and homemade pastas. There are three dining options: the rustic dining area, the lively bar, and the patio where you can enjoy the water view. La Sponda’s menu is intentional, each dish pairing brilliantly with another. For an appetizer, try the stuffed dates, wrapped with prosciutto and filled with gorgonzola and cream sauce. You can’t leave without trying one of their many pasta dishes – will you opt for the short rib ravioli or linguini with clams?
Pomod’oro Pizza and Italian Restaurant | 200 Chestnut Street
Owner Croce “Tony” Cataldo originates from Carini, Palermo in Sicily. In 1980, at the age of 16, he left home and made his way to the States. With the immense success of his first restaurant, Anthony’s in Malvern, he decided it was time for a second location, this time in Downingtown. Pomod’oro has an approachable menu, filled with classics such as lasgna, baked ziti, and shrimp scampi. However, there are some dishes that push the envelope – have you tried their Pasta DiMare, a fresh pasta dish with mussels, clams, shrimp, scallops, and crab meat?
Anthony’s Cucina Fresca | 78 W. Lancaster Avenue
Anthony’s Cucina Fresca brings a unique twist to traditional dining. The warm hospitality, paired with tempting cocktails and delicious food, provide the perfect experience for a date night, birthday dinner, or any celebration. Anthony’s leans into the Italian tradition of spending time with loved ones over a nice meal. Some of their popular dishes include Anthony’s eggplant – sliced eggplant baked and topped with marinara sauce, mozzarella, Romano cheese, basil, and olive oil – and baked stuffed oysters, prepared with mushrooms, spinach, pancetta, and cream cheese.
The Orangery | 130 S. Lloyd Avenue
The Orangery defines themselves as Tuscan, bringing the vibrant flavors of the historic region to Downingtown. Dinner seating is available Thursday through Saturday starting at 6:30 PM. Their menus change frequently, and dishes are to be selected at the time of reservation. Vegetarian options are available; please request when making your reservation. The Orangery’s latest menu featured eggplant crostini, caprese, chicken saltimbocca, pasta with vodka sauce, and more. Their decadent desserts are always the perfect ending to a luxurious meal.
Lione’s Pizza Restaurant | 116 Wallace Avenue
Lione’s is a family-owned business, providing casual Italian fare in a friendly atmosphere. The Lione’s menu is extensive and will sure to satisfy the entire family or dining group. Homemade is their specialty – their salads, soups, pastas, and pizza dough are created fresh every day. Pizzas are served by the box or by the slice, including specialities such as BBQ Chicken pizza and pickle ranch pizza. On top of pizza and pasta, the restaurant also offers cold subs, hot subs, burgers, and strombolis.
Michelangelo’s Italian Restaurant | 1223 Horseshoe Pike
Michelangelo’s takes a modern approach to this traditional cuisine. On their menu, you can expect to find cheesesteaks, hot sandwiches, paninis, burgers, wraps, calzones, and pasta. The restaurant is kid friendly, offering dishes such as chicken fingers and fries, grilled cheese, ravioli, and spaghetti. Michelangelo’s also provides catering to make any event run seamlessly.
Is this list missing your favorite Italian restaurant in Downingtown? Let us know!
Dovetail Auctions is a unique, local business that sells antiques and artwork through their online auctions. Learn more about them here.
